Charles Johnston, Jonah and the nature of Prophecy

You know the story of Jonah and Nineveh, right?  Jonah was commanded by God to warn Nineveh that, because of their wickedness, they had forty days to live.  At first, Jonah disobeyed but then Jonah obeyed God and warned the Ninevites of their impending doom.

Lo and behold, the Ninevites were scared straight!  They immediately put on sack cloth and ashes and repented of their sins, calling on the Lord to save them.  And the Lord did.
Let’s say it happened today
Let’s say that, instead of this happening 6000 years ago, in ancient Nineveh, it happened today.  Let’s say that a modern day Jonah were to appear and warn the world of impending doom.  And the world repented sufficiently so that the doom was averted.
Do you know what would happen?
The headlines would read, “False prophet!  His prophecy didn’t come true!”  Yeah, that’s right.  Instead of thanking God for His great mercy shown upon the world, the world would turn upon the fellow that had warned them and thus saved them from impending doom.
Well folks, it is happening today
There are several people out there, who feel called by God to warn people of impending suffering and perhaps doom.  Charlie Johnston and other Catholic Seers claim they have received warnings from God and they are passing them on to us.
I’ve seen several articles in Catholic circles, warning people not to take Charlie Johnston and other alleged seers, like himself, too seriously.   They say that these things generally don’t come true.  They fail to account for the reason why they haven’t come true in the past.  Because of God’s mercy towards His elect.
The Church tells us how to discern these prophecies
Prophecies which contradict the Teaching of the Church, should be disregarded.  But, these prophecies, as far as I see, are completely in line with Church Teaching and in fact, they instruct us to observe all Church Teaching and to be obedient to the Church.
Year of Mercy
Is it coincidental that these prophecies are supposed to come true in 2017 and 2016 is the Year of Mercy?  I doubt it.
We don’t want these prophecies to come true
I know I don’t.  I’m sure Charlie and all the rest of these Seers would tell you that neither you nor they want these prophecies to come true.  In order to avert these prophecies, we need to imitate the Ninevites.  We need to repent of our sins.  We need to call out to God.  We need to pray for His mercy.
That’s the whole purpose of the warnings, if they are from God.  It is because of His merciful love that He wants us to repent of our sins and turn to Him.  Otherwise, He wouldn’t send any warnings.
Whether you be Catholic, Protestant, Jew or whatever.  We need to unite before God.  We need to become one in love and call out for His mercy.
What if these warnings are false?
Let’s hope they are false.  But that’s not going to stop me from turning to God more and more each day.  Because even if these warnings are false, I know that I’m not going to live forever.  Someday, I will die.  And I don’t know the day nor the hour.  Therefore, I want to be as perfect as God wills for me to be, on that day.
The point of this article
The Ninevites didn’t sit around examining Jonah’s message when he came around with his warning.  They recognized that it was true and they admitted their sins and cried out to God for mercy.  Look around.  We live in a world-wide Nineveh.  It’s time to put on sack cloth and ashes.  It’s time to cry out for God’s mercy, again.


  1. Mark T.

    Charlie Johnson has YET to be rebuked for his teachings being against Church Teaching. In fact, his Bishop hasn’t even spoken out against it, neither his priest. While we’ve already been warned thanks to Fatima, I think continued warning is necessary the way our country (and world for that matter) conduct themselves.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. annamaria

    Hi. Im kinda sitting on the fence with all of this. I comment on Charlies Blogs, I relish his writings only. However, I have found him to be very proud and sometimes offensive. I also feel like he demeans or maybe, diminishes women. He very rarely comments when a woman replies and if he does its, well rude. I have reservations because he has made snide remarks about his mother and said he was a single dad, as if he gave birth to his children. I skip over his comments on his blog because it hurts my heart to read his…all i can say..disrespectful comments if one person disagrees


    • De Maria

      Did you read the conversation I had with him? I simply don’t trust a Catholic who believes he has the authority to criticize Bishops. They are the image of Christ for us. To boast that he will criticize Bishops, is tanamount to boasting that he will criticize Christ.

      1549 Through the ordained ministry, especially that of bishops and priests, the presence of Christ as head of the Church is made visible in the midst of the community of believers. In the beautiful expression of St. Ignatius of Antioch, the bishop is typos tou Patros: he is like the living image of God the Father.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s